SecretSkies

How SecretSkies works

SecretSkies works by creating an edited version at the ATProto record layer. Bsky proper keeps showing the original, but compatible third-party apps and forked communities may show the update.

?The honest answer for anyone searching for a Bluesky edit button.

How it works

Four steps, no mythology.

The product is easier to understand when you separate Bsky proper from the wider ATProto ecosystem.

  • Bsky is one view of ATProto.
  • Some communities use their own views.
  • SecretSkies updates the underlying record.
  • Compatible views can show the update.

Key takeaway

SecretSkies does not force an edit into Bsky proper. It updates the post record underneath, then compatible community views can decide to show that edited version.

The simple version

  1. You post on Bluesky.
  2. Bsky proper keeps showing the original.
  3. SecretSkies creates an edited version in the underlying ATProto record.
  4. A compatible third-party app or forked community can show that edited version.

Why it is not universal

Not every app reads posts the same way. Some surfaces are conservative and keep the original. Others may use the updated record. That difference is exactly where SecretSkies can be useful.

Why communities might want it

A community may want to support corrections, clarifications, typo fixes, updated links, or local norms without waiting for Bsky proper to add a universal edit feature.

FAQ

Does SecretSkies hack Bluesky?

No. It uses the ATProto layer in a way compatible views may understand.

Why does Bsky still show the original?

Bsky proper chooses to show the original version.

Why can another community show something else?

Third-party apps and forked communities can make different choices about which record version to display.